Skip to main content
CallSprout
2017-04-19

7 Ways to Prescreen Your Next Hire on the Phone

7 tips for phone prescreens: prepare your questions, set expectations, keep your tone friendly, and let candidates ask theirs before you book a full interview.

Connected green puzzle pieces beside an ivory business telephone

Anybody can look good on paper, but can they walk their talk?

This resume just rocketed to the top of the pile. There's a checkmark next to every keyword. You have to wonder if this person is too good to be true. The only way to find out is a phone call or video conference.

Prescreening job candidates saves you time and money. Resume-writing services can make just about anybody look awesome, so you need a glimpse of the real person before you invest in the next step. These 7 tips will help you decide if a prospect is worth it.

1. Don't wing it

Make notes all over that resume. Write a list of questions you want to explore, then rank them by need-to-know. That matters if you tend to get sidetracked.

You're not the only one being scrutinized on a phone prescreen. The prospect will draw conclusions, too. Will one of them be that you don't respect their time? Know what you're looking for. It may be a process of discovery, but you're not spelunking.

2. Preselect your questions and stick to them

You already have a clear picture of the candidate who'd be best for this position. Every question should have one purpose: to show whether this prospect fits that picture.

Skip generic questions like, "How do you see your career 10 years from now?" Do you even have an answer for that one? Ask practical questions that produce insight, and keep them about what a candidate can do for your company now based on examples of what they did in the past.

3. Manage expectations

Good interviewers get the information they need by setting the stage. They explain how the interview will go and what they want out of it.

Video calls are one of the best ways to do this. The candidate can see you, and you can see them, so you can tell whether they understand and accept the process you outline.

It keeps you focused, too. On a video call you're less tempted to sneak a look at an incoming email or anything else that pulls your mind off the task.

4. Keep your tone in check

The days are gone when a company could act like it held all the cards just because it had a job to offer, if those days ever existed. A good candidate knows their value, and you wouldn't have scheduled the call unless you saw it too.

Good interviewers make people feel welcome and appreciated. It puts candidates at ease and gets them talking.

We all talk faster when we're passionate about a subject. Watch for that on the call and keep your pace casual. It sets the atmosphere you want and leaves you free to pick up the cues you need.

5. Start off by telling them about yourself

If you've ever been the candidate on a prescreen call, you may have wondered why the interviewer opened with a "let me tell you about myself" moment. They weren't making it all about them. They were making it all about you.

The point is to show the candidate how to present the kind of information you want from them. A candidate can't read your mind, so you lead by example.

6. Make it conversational

Your candidate is the focus and should do most of the talking. Good interviewers know how to facilitate. They do it 3 ways:

  • Direct the flow
  • Keep the focus
  • Maintain the tempo

If your candidate starts to ramble or drifts off-topic, interject politely, tell them you get what they're saying, and move to the next topic. There's an art to conversation. Keep things on track.

That also means watching the clock. You can help a candidate organize their thoughts by managing the time in a conversational way.

  • Let them know when you've reached the halfway point.
  • Give them a heads-up when only a few minutes are left.
  • Tell them how many questions you have left.

7. They've got questions, too

If you don't let a candidate ask questions, as many as you did or even more, you're missing a real chance to learn about them. It's also impolite. Listen for the questions you want to hear the candidate ask.

What they ask shows you their concerns and priorities:

  • Do those match the picture you have of this position?
  • Are they mostly about procedures and timing?
  • Or are they about your company's culture?

Questions show what motivates a person. Are there right or wrong questions? That's your call. There should be some, though. You want to know they're curious about your company and the job.

Clear communication wins the call

Draw your own conclusion if a candidate takes the call from a coffee shop or while driving through a tunnel. But be fair, and allow for the fact that where they are in their career may make a private space hard to find.

It's a different story for you as the interviewer. You set this up. Ideally it's a video call so you get all the visual cues. A dropped call or choppy audio in the middle of a key answer is a distraction you can avoid. A cloud business phone system that runs on a 99.999% uptime reliability network keeps your prescreen calls clear from the first hello to the final question.

Let your phone system handle the busywork

A busy hiring season brings a flood of inbound calls, voicemails, and scheduling back-and-forth. The CallSprout AI Voice Agent can answer candidate calls, transcribe the conversation so you have a searchable record of every screen, and route the right callers to the right people on your team. That frees your day for the prescreen calls that matter, and a promising candidate doesn't end up in a dead-end voicemail box.

If hiring season is heavy on calls at your company, book a demo and see how CallSprout fits your screening process.

See CallSprout in action.

Start a free trial or talk to Sage, our AI agent.

Get a live call from our AI agent in about 10 seconds.